Skip to main content

Advanced Quantum Mechanics course sequence · Interactive lesson

Covariant notation and the Klein-Gordon equation

Here the course fixes the notation it is written in, and spends it at once on the first relativistic wave equation. One substitution into the mass-shell condition gives an equation every inertial observer agrees on, and a spectrum with a second, negative branch that nothing in the equation removes. Unit 3 is the story of that branch.

UAQM-03.01 · Lesson 1 of 9 in this unit. Position is not a completion score.
Starting model: Covariant notation and the Klein-Gordon equationThe free Klein-Gordon spectrum E² = p²c² + m²c⁴ for mc² = 140 MeV, with E and pc on equal scales so the dashed light cone E = ±pc runs at 45°. At pc = 100 MeV the two dots are the two roots, E = ±172.0 MeV; at p = 0 they are 2mc² = 280 MeV apart. Each tangent's slope is a group velocity, 0.581c in size. The dashed parabola is mc² + p²/2m.E / MeVpc / MeVsolid: E² = p²c² + m²c⁴dots: E = ±172.0 MeVtangents: |v|/c = 0.581dashed lines: E = ±pcdashed curve: mc² + p²/2m
Start with a picture. Change the model in the lab below.
1

Build the model

Square the energy instead of rooting it, and relativity hands you a second branch.

The key idea

The Klein-Gordon equation, (1/c²)∂²φ/∂t² − ∇²φ + (mc/ħ)²φ = 0, is the wave equation obtained by making E²/c² − p² = m²c² an operator identity with E = iħ∂/∂t and p = −iħ∇; written as (□ + (mc/ħ)²)φ = 0 it has the same form in every inertial frame.

Example. For a charged pion mc² = 139.57 MeV, so ħ/mc = 197.33 MeV fm ÷ 139.57 MeV = 1.414 fm. A plane wave with pc = 200 MeV solves the equation with E = +243.9 MeV, and equally with E = −243.9 MeV.

The complete physical model and assumptions

Quantum Mechanics I turned energy and momentum into operators, iħ∂/∂t and −iħ∇, and fed them the Galilean relation E = p²/2m: first order in time and second order in space, a mismatch no Lorentz transformation can respect. Special relativity offers instead the invariant pμpμ = E²/c² − p² = m²c². With xμ = (ct, x), the metric diag(1, −1, −1, −1) and ∂μ = ∂/∂xμ, Quantum Mechanics I's two rules become one four-vector statement, pμ = iħ∂μ, and substituting it gives (□ + (mc/ħ)²)φ = 0 with □ = ∂μ∂μ, derived. Every index in it is contracted, so a scalar φ obeys the same equation in every inertial frame. The price of avoiding a square root is a second time derivative. Plane waves e(−i(Et − p⋅x)/ħ) solve the equation for E = +√(p²c² + m²c⁴) and equally for E = −√(p²c² + m²c⁴); the general solution needs both φ and ∂φ/∂t at t = 0, and generic data fill both branches. The one new length is ħ/mc, and at wavelengths below it, or kinetic energies of order mc², the second branch is no small correction. As a field equation for spin-0 particles such as the pion the result survives, and Unit 9 returns to it. As a one-particle wave equation it fails, and the rest of Unit 3 shows how: an indefinite density, missing spin terms in hydrogen, and no ground state in a strong Coulomb field.

1Fix the conventions once

Units are SI with ħ and c kept, and the metric is gμν = diag(1, −1, −1, −1), for the rest of the course. Coordinates form xμ = (ct, x), so x⁰ = ct is a length. Lowering an index flips the spatial sign, xμ = (ct, −x), and a contraction reads aμbμ = a⁰b⁰ − a⋅b. A derivative with respect to an upper-index coordinate carries a lower index, ∂μ = ∂/∂xμ = (∂/∂(ct), ∇), and raising it gives ∂μ = (∂/∂(ct), −∇). The four-momentum is pμ = (E/c, p), and Quantum Mechanics I's rules E = iħ∂/∂t and p = −iħ∇ assemble into one statement, pμ = iħ∂μ: the time component is iħ(1/c)∂/∂t = E/c, and the spatial components are iħ∂k = −iħ∂/∂xk. Test it on Quantum Mechanics I's plane wave, ⟨x|p⟩ ∝ e(ip⋅x/ħ) times e(−iEt/ħ), which is e(−ipμxμ/ħ) with pμxμ = Et − p⋅x: iħ∂μ returns pμ times the wave. Lorentz matrices Λμν and the invariant E²/c² − p² = m²c² come from special relativity and are used, not re-derived.

2Square the energy rather than take its root

The obvious relativistic Hamiltonian is H = √(p²c² + m²c⁴). With p = −iħ∇ it becomes √(m²c⁴ − ħ²c²∇²), whose expansion mc² − ħ²∇²/2m − ħ⁴∇⁴/(8m³c²) − … contains every power of ∇: an operator that ties φ at one point to φ up to about ħ/mc away, and treats time, one derivative, and space, all orders, so unequally that nothing about it is manifestly covariant. Use the square instead. Acting on φ, pμpμ = (iħ)²∂μ∂μ = −ħ²□, so pμpμφ = m²c²φ becomes (□ + (mc/ħ)²)φ = 0 with □ = (1/c²)∂²/∂t² − ∇², derived. Dimensions: ∇² is m⁻², and mc/ħ is kg m s⁻¹ over J s, which is m⁻¹; for the electron (mc/ħ)² = 6.71 × 10²⁴ m⁻². Limit m → 0: d'Alembert's □φ = 0, which each Lorenz-gauge potential obeys in vacuum, quoted from electromagnetism. Klein, Gordon, Fock and Schrödinger all published the equation in 1926, Schrödinger having first written it down late in 1925, quoted.

3One equation for every inertial observer

A Lorentz transformation x′μ = Λμν xν preserves the metric, so any contraction of an upper index with a lower one has the same value in every frame. ∂μ transforms with the inverse matrix, so □ = ∂μ∂μ is a scalar operator, and if φ is a scalar field, φ′(x′) = φ(x), then (□′ + (mc/ħ)²)φ′ = 0 holds in the new frame whenever (□ + (mc/ħ)²)φ = 0 held in the old: derived. Check it by hand for a boost at βc along x. From ct′ = γ(ct − βx) and x′ = γ(x − βct), the chain rule gives ∂/∂(ct) = γ(∂′₀ − β∂′ₓ) and ∂/∂x = γ(∂′ₓ − β∂′₀), so ∂₀² − ∂ₓ² = γ²(1 − β²)(∂′₀² − ∂′ₓ²), and γ²(1 − β²) = 1. Schrödinger's iħ∂ψ/∂t = −(ħ²/2m)∇²ψ fails the same test, one time derivative against two space derivatives, and survives only Galilean boosts, with a phase. The plane-wave phase pμxμ = Et − p⋅x is itself a contraction, so a solution in one frame is a solution in any other, with E and p transformed as a four-vector.

4Two signs of energy, and nothing to choose between them

Substitute φ = e(−i(Et − p⋅x)/ħ): ∂²/∂t² brings −E²/ħ², ∇² brings −p²/ħ², and the equation becomes E²/c² − p² − m²c² = 0, so E = ±Eₚ with Eₚ = √(p²c² + m²c⁴), derived. The branches are mirror hyperbolas 2mc² apart at p = 0, 1.022 MeV for the electron and 279.1 MeV for the charged pion, and a squared equation prefers neither. Being second order in time, the equation has two amplitudes per momentum in its general solution, a(p) on e(−iEₚt/ħ) and b(p) on e(+iEₚt/ħ), fixed by two initial data, φ and ∂φ/∂t at t = 0. A pulse with ∂φ/∂t = 0 at t = 0 gets a = b: half of it is negative-energy wave. Because |E| exceeds |p|c on the mass shell, free evolution and boosts never change the sign of E, so for a free particle the split is consistent. But keeping only b = 0 means imposing the square-root equation on the data, and a perturbation with ħω ≥ 2mc², ω above 1.55 × 10²¹ s⁻¹ for the electron, couples the two branches. Topic 3.02 shows what the lower branch does to the density.

5The Compton wavelength sets the scale

The equation contains a single length, λC = ħ/mc, the reduced Compton wavelength: 386.16 fm for the electron, 1.868 fm for the muon, 1.414 fm for the charged pion and 0.2103 fm for the proton, from measured masses. The wave number in units of it, kλC = p/mc, says which regime a wave is in. For p ≪ mc the upper branch is mc² + p²/2m − p⁴/(8m³c²) + …, rest energy, Schrödinger's kinetic energy and Quantum Mechanics II's correction, which topic 3.03 recovers from the equation itself. At p = mc the exact kinetic energy is (√2 − 1)mc² = 0.414mc², and the non-relativistic 0.5mc² is 21% high. The group velocity, dE/dp = pc²/E from the spectrum, stays below c on both branches while the phase velocity E/p exceeds c in size, their product being c². A packet squeezed below λC contains momenta above mc and energies where the second branch is no small correction. The length is measured directly: Compton's X-ray shift at 90° is h/(mₑc) = 2πλC = 2.4263 pm, quoted.

6A static source: the Compton wavelength as a range

For a time-independent φ the equation reads ∇²φ = φ/λC². Away from a point source, with spherical symmetry, (1/r)d²(rφ)/dr² = φ/λC², so rφ = A e(−r/λC) + B e(r/λC), and decay at large r keeps φ = A e(−r/λC)/r, derived: Coulomb's 1/r cut off over one Compton wavelength, returning exactly to 1/r in the massless limit m → 0. Yukawa in 1935 read the short range of the nuclear force, about 2 fm, as the λC of a new particle and predicted a mass near 200 mₑ, quoted. The charged pion, found in 1947, has mc² = 139.57 MeV, which is 273 mₑ, and λC = 1.414 fm, quoted. Reading the static solution as a force carried by particles is field theory and waits for Unit 9. As a fact about the equation alone it already says that a massive scalar field cannot reach much further than ħ/mc from its source.

2

Key equations

Read the units, assumptions and limits before substituting.

Four-momentum as a derivative

pμ = iħ∂μ, so E = iħ ∂/∂t and p = −iħ∇

The minus sign in ∂k = −∂/∂xk is the metric's, and it is what returns Quantum Mechanics I's p = −iħ∇. On e(−i(Et − p⋅x)/ħ) the operator returns the eigenvalues (E/c, p).

xμ = (ct, x); gμν = diag(1, −1, −1, −1); ∂μ = (∂/∂(ct), −∇); E in J, p in kg m s⁻¹. A definition, matched to QM I.

The Klein-Gordon equation

(□ + (mc/ħ)²)φ = 0, with □ = ∂μ∂μ = (1/c²)∂²/∂t² − ∇²

Every index is contracted, so a scalar φ obeys it in every inertial frame. At m = 0 it is d'Alembert's wave equation, with E = ±pc.

φ a scalar field; □ and (mc/ħ)² both in m⁻²; m the rest mass in kg. Derived from pμpμ = m²c² with pμ = iħ∂μ.

Plane-wave spectrum

E = ±Eₚ, Eₚ = √(p²c² + m²c⁴), for φ = e(−i(Et − p⋅x)/ħ)

Both signs solve the equation at every p and nothing in it chooses. For pc ≪ mc², +Eₚ ≈ mc² + p²/2m: the Schrödinger energy on top of the rest energy.

E, pc and mc² in J or MeV. Derived by substitution. The branches are 2mc² apart at p = 0: 1.022 MeV for the electron.

Compton wavelength, the equation's one length

λC = ħ/mc

kλC = p/mc says how relativistic a wave is. The static solution e(−r/λC)/r makes λC a range as well: 1.41 fm for the pion.

In m. 386.16 fm for the electron, 1.414 fm for the charged pion, 0.2103 fm for the proton; h/mc = 2πλC. Measured masses, quoted.

Group velocity on both branches

vg = dE/dp = pc²/E

On the upper branch a packet moves along p. On the lower, E is negative and the packet moves against its own momentum.

In m s⁻¹, with E = ±Eₚ. |vg| = |p|c²/Eₚ is below c whenever m is non-zero. Derived. The phase velocity E/p exceeds c in size.

General solution needs two initial data

φ = ∫ d³p [a(p) e(−iEₚt/ħ) + b(p) e(iEₚt/ħ)] e(ip⋅x/ħ)

Second order in time means two amplitudes for each momentum, projected out of the data: with φ̃ the Fourier amplitude at t = 0, a = [φ̃ + (iħ/Eₚ)∂φ̃/∂t]/2 and b = [φ̃ − (iħ/Eₚ)∂φ̃/∂t]/2.

a(p) and b(p) are fixed by φ and ∂φ/∂t at t = 0. b = 0 only if iħ∂φ/∂t = √(m²c⁴ − ħ²c²∇²)φ initially. Derived.
3

Interactive lab

Predict first. Explore the model. Compare the result.

Explore the model

140 MeV
10 to 200 MeV; steps of 10.
100 MeV
−200 to 200 MeV; steps of 10.

Try this. At mc² = 140 MeV, close to the pion's 139.6, sweep pc from 0 to 200 MeV: the parabola leaves the upper branch once pc nears mc², and both tangents stay shallower than the light cone. Then drop mc² to 10 MeV: the gap closes and both branches hug E = ±pc, but the lower one never goes away.

Live results

ROOTS E = ±√(p²c² + m²c⁴)
172.0 MeV
GROUP SPEED |dE/dp|/c
0.581
COMPTON LENGTH ħ/mc
1.41 fm
|p|/mc
0.71

Results follow this lesson’s model and assumptions. Displayed values are rounded.

Interactive Advanced Quantum Mechanics modelThe free Klein-Gordon spectrum E² = p²c² + m²c⁴ for mc² = 140 MeV, with E and pc on equal scales so the dashed light cone E = ±pc runs at 45°. At pc = 100 MeV the two dots are the two roots, E = ±172.0 MeV; at p = 0 they are 2mc² = 280 MeV apart. Each tangent's slope is a group velocity, 0.581c in size. The dashed parabola is mc² + p²/2m.E / MeVpc / MeVsolid: E² = p²c² + m²c⁴dots: E = ±172.0 MeVtangents: |v|/c = 0.581dashed lines: E = ±pcdashed curve: mc² + p²/2m
The free Klein-Gordon spectrum E² = p²c² + m²c⁴ for mc² = 140 MeV, with E and pc on equal scales so the dashed light cone E = ±pc runs at 45°. At pc = 100 MeV the two dots are the two roots, E = ±172.0 MeV; at p = 0 they are 2mc² = 280 MeV apart. Each tangent's slope is a group velocity, 0.581c in size. The dashed parabola is mc² + p²/2m.

Predict → change one variable → check

Plan a change before running it. Every other input stays at the saved baseline.

Saved baseline. Rest energy mc²: 140 MeV; Momentum pc: 100 MeV

Baseline 140; choose 10 to 200, in steps of 10.
4. Compared with the saved baseline, this result will…

This experiment is kept only while this page is open. It does not change saved course progress.

4

Catch the common trap

The tempting move is to treat E = −√(p²c² + m²c⁴) like the unphysical root of a quadratic in a mechanics problem and drop it. The equation gives no licence for that. It is second order in time, so a solution is fixed by φ and ∂φ/∂t together, and those data set two amplitudes for every momentum, one on each branch: a pulse launched with ∂φ/∂t = 0 is half negative-energy wave. Keeping only positive E means demanding iħ∂φ/∂t = √(m²c⁴ − ħ²c²∇²)φ of the data, which is the non-local square-root equation the squaring was meant to avoid. Free motion and boosts keep the branches apart, but a perturbation with ħω ≥ 2mc² couples them, and with the lower branch present the energy has no floor. The second sign is a property of the equation that later topics must interpret, not a root to be thrown away.

5

Practice & worked examples

3 authored examples. Make an attempt, then reveal the reasoning one step at a time.

EasyExample 1

An electron, mc² = 0.5110 MeV, has a plane-wave component with pc = 1.000 MeV. Check that (mc/ħ)² has the dimensions of ∇², then find ħ/mc, ħ/p, both energies the Klein-Gordon equation allows, and how far the non-relativistic kinetic energy p²/2m is off. Use ħc = 197.33 MeV fm.

Sketch your answer or reasoning, then compare it with the authored solution. Your writing is not automatically graded or saved.

0 of 4 steps revealed.

MediumExample 2

A Klein-Gordon plane wave has momentum along +x with pc = 2.4mc² and energy E = −2.6mc². Find its group velocity, the boost velocity that brings its momentum to zero and its energy in that frame, and show that no boost makes its energy positive. Give the energies in MeV for a charged pion, mc² = 139.57 MeV.

Sketch your answer or reasoning, then compare it with the authored solution. Your writing is not automatically graded or saved.

0 of 5 steps revealed.

HardExample 3

A packet is launched with φ(x, 0) = g(x) and ∂φ/∂t(x, 0) = −(imc²/ħ)g(x), the time dependence of a particle at rest. Show that each momentum component of g splits into a positive-energy amplitude a(p) and a negative-energy amplitude b(p) with b/a = (Eₚ − mc²)/(Eₚ + mc²). Evaluate it for a charged pion component with pc = 100 MeV, at p = mc, and for an electron with p = αmc, typical of hydrogen.

Sketch your answer or reasoning, then compare it with the authored solution. Your writing is not automatically graded or saved.

0 of 5 steps revealed.

6

Quick check

Select an answer and explain it before checking.

With xμ = (ct, x), the metric diag(1, −1, −1, −1) and pμ = iħ∂μ, a student turns pμpμ = m²c² into an operator equation acting on φ. Which equation should result?
7

Review & continue

The Klein-Gordon equation, (1/c²)∂²φ/∂t² − ∇²φ + (mc/ħ)²φ = 0, is the wave equation obtained by making E²/c² − p² = m²c² an operator identity with E = iħ∂/∂t and p = −iħ∇; written as (□ + (mc/ħ)²)φ = 0 it has the same form in every inertial frame.

  • Explain the relationship without looking at the equation.
  • Check a sign, a unit and a model assumption in your working.
  • Return to the lab or worked example if a step is still unclear.

Extra challenging questions

Connect several ideas, explore supplied data, and compare your reasoning with a worked solution.