
Bounded modern-physics survey · Interactive lesson
The Schrödinger equation for the Coulomb potential
This is the calculation the rest of atomic physics leans on. We split the hydrogen equation in two, turn its radial half into a particle in an effective potential, and let three boundary conditions, not three postulates, hand us m, l and n, and the −13.6 eV/n² ladder with them.
UPIII-10.03 · Lesson 3 of 9 in this unit. Position is not a completion score.Bounded modern-physics survey. This modern-physics material is an introductory survey, not a complete course in relativity, quantum, atomic, nuclear or particle physics. Your university determines the required depth and assessment.
Build the model
Three boundary conditions, three integers, one energy ladder.
The key idea
The Coulomb-potential Schrödinger equation describes one electron bound by −ke²/r to a fixed point nucleus; separated in spherical coordinates, it has normalisable solutions only for integer m, l and n, with the energy set by n alone.
Example. Try E = −10.0 eV with l = 0. The solution that vanishes at the nucleus has κ = 0.857/a₀, so 1/(κa₀) = 1.17 is not an integer, its series never stops, and u grows like e(+κr). At E = −13.6 eV, κa₀ = 1 and u = r e(−r/a₀) decays.
The complete physical model and assumptions
Hydrogen is the one atom whose Schrödinger equation can be solved exactly, and the solution shows where quantum numbers come from. The model is one spinless, non-relativistic electron bound by −ke²/r to a nucleus treated as a fixed point. Because the potential depends on r alone, spherical coordinates split the equation into an angular problem that every central force shares and a radial problem that alone feels the Coulomb term. Writing u = rR turns the radial problem into a one-dimensional particle in an effective potential: the Coulomb well plus a centrifugal wall l(l+1)ħ²/(2mr²). Nothing is quantised by decree. The angular function must be single-valued, which forces an integer m; it must stay finite at the poles, which forces l(l+1) with l ≥ |m|; u = rR must vanish at the nucleus and decay at infinity, and it can do both only if its power series stops, which forces n = nᵣ + l + 1 and E = −13.6 eV/n². Bohr's energies come back, now with a ground state of zero angular momentum. The model stops where its idealisations do: the nucleus recoils, shifting every level by about 0.05%; relativity and spin–orbit coupling enter at order α²; and a second electron destroys the single central potential that made the separation possible.
1Spherical symmetry splits one equation into two
For one electron bound to a fixed proton, −(ħ²/2m)∇²ψ − (ke²/r)ψ = Eψ with k = 1/(4πε₀). The potential depends on r = √(x² + y² + z²), which ties x, y and z together, so no product X(x)Y(y)Z(z) can work. Spherical coordinates untie them: ∇² = (1/r²)∂/∂r(r² ∂/∂r) + Λ/r², where Λ holds only θ and φ derivatives. Try ψ = R(r)Y(θ, φ) and multiply through by −2mr²/(ħ²RY). What remains is a function of r alone plus ΛY/Y, a function of the angles alone, summing to zero everywhere, so each must be a constant: ΛY = −λY, and λ passes into the radial equation. Notice where the Coulomb term went: only into the radial half. The angular problem is the same for every central potential. Dimensions fix the scales before anything is solved: ħ, m and ke² form exactly one length, a₀ = ħ²/(mke²) = 52.9 pm, and one energy, ke²/a₀ = 27.2 eV.
2Single-valuedness gives m; regularity at the poles gives l
Split once more, Y = Θ(θ)Φ(φ). The φ part obeys d²Φ/dφ² = −m²Φ, so Φ = e(imφ). The angles φ and φ + 2π name the same point, and ψ may take only one value there, so e(2πim) = 1 and m is an integer. Try m = ½: then Φ(2π) = −Φ(0), a wavefunction with two values at one place. The θ part, written in x = cos θ, is the associated Legendre equation. Its power-series solutions diverge at x = 1 or x = −1, the two poles, unless the series terminates, and it terminates only when λ = l(l+1) with l a whole number and l ≥ |m|. So l = 2 allows m = −2, −1, 0, 1, 2: five states, 2l + 1 in general. Two things to notice. The Coulomb potential has not yet been used, so these integers belong to every central force. And m never appears in the radial equation, only λ does, so the energy cannot depend on m: with no field applied, nothing picks out the z axis.
3The radial equation is a one-dimensional well
Substitute u(r) = rR(r). Because (1/r²)d/dr(r² dR/dr) = (1/r)d²u/dr², the radial equation becomes −(ħ²/2m)u″ + Ueff(r)u = Eu, with Ueff = −ke²/r + l(l+1)ħ²/(2mr²): a particle on the half-line r > 0. The added term is the kinetic energy of angular motion, L²/(2mr²) with L² = l(l+1)ħ², the centrifugal term of classical orbit theory. Using ħ²/m = ke²a₀, Ueff = ke²[−1/r + l(l+1)a₀/(2r²)], and dUeff/dr = 0 at r = l(l+1)a₀, where Ueff = −13.6 eV/[l(l+1)]. For l = 1 the floor is at 2a₀ = 106 pm and −6.80 eV; for l = 2 at 6a₀ = 318 pm and −2.27 eV. Raising l pushes the well outwards and makes it shallower. Only l = 0 has no wall: the Coulomb well deepens all the way in, and s states alone reach the nucleus. The substitution also tidies normalisation, since |ψ|² d³r = |u|² dr |Y|² dΩ, so ∫₀^∞ |u|² dr = 1.
4Each end of the radial line imposes a condition
Near r = 0 try a power law, u = rˢ. Then u″ and the centrifugal term both go as r(s−2), while the Coulomb term goes only as r(s−1) and the E term as rˢ, so as r → 0 the first two must balance on their own: u″ ≈ l(l+1)u/r², which needs s(s − 1) = l(l+1), so s = l + 1 or s = −l. The second is rejected: for l ≥ 1 it makes ∫|u|² dr diverge at the origin, and for l = 0 it gives R ∝ 1/r, whose Laplacian is a δ function that the 1/r Coulomb term cannot balance. So u(0) = 0 and u ∝ r(l+1). Far out both potential terms fade and u″ ≈ κ²u with κ = √(−2mE)/ħ, giving e(−κr) or e(+κr); normalisation keeps only the first. At E = −13.6 eV, κ = 1/a₀, a decay length of 52.9 pm. Now count. A second-order equation has two independent solutions; the condition at r = 0 picks one and leaves only its scale free. Whether that solution also decays at infinity is not yours to choose, and for most E it does not. That mismatch, not a rule added by hand, is what makes the energy discrete.
5The series must stop, and n is where it stops
Factor out both ends: u = r(l+1) e(−κr) v(r), with v = Σ cⱼ rʲ. Substituting gives cⱼ₊₁ = 2[κ(j + l + 1) − 1/a₀] cⱼ / [(j + 1)(j + 2l + 2)]. For large j the ratio tends to 2κ/j, the ratio in the series for e(2κr), so a series that never ends makes u grow like e(+κr) and fail at infinity. The only escape is a numerator that vanishes at some j = nᵣ, which needs κa₀(nᵣ + l + 1) = 1. Call n = nᵣ + l + 1. Then κ = 1/(na₀) and E = −ħ²κ²/(2m) = −ke²/(2a₀n²) = −13.6 eV/n², with v a polynomial of degree nᵣ and n ≥ l + 1. The ground state is nᵣ = 0, l = 0: Bohr's energy with zero angular momentum instead of Bohr's ħ. Correspondence holds at large n: from n = 100 to 101 the spacing is 2.68 × 10⁻⁵ eV, within 1.5% of h times the classical orbital frequency at that energy, 27.2 eV/n³ = 2.72 × 10⁻⁵ eV.
6What the solution leaves out
Four idealisations were built in, and each has a price. An infinitely heavy nucleus: in fact both particles orbit the centre of mass, and the exact fix is to replace m by the reduced mass μ = mM/(m + M). For hydrogen μ = 0.999456 mₑ, so E₁ = −13.598 eV rather than −13.606 eV, 7.4 meV shallower; deuterium's correction is half as large, which puts its Balmer-α line 0.18 nm short of hydrogen's 656 nm line, the shift by which deuterium was first identified. Non-relativistic motion: the electron moves at about αc = c/137, so relativistic corrections have relative size α² ≈ 5 × 10⁻⁵, of order 7 × 10⁻⁴ eV at n = 1, and for a hydrogen-like ion they grow as (Zα)². No spin: the equation cannot produce spin–orbit splitting or the factor of 2 in a shell's capacity; both arrive later in this section. A point nucleus: the proton's 0.84 fm radius is 1.6 × 10⁻⁵ a₀, and it lifts the 1s level by only about 5 × 10⁻⁹ eV. Each correction shifts or splits levels; none changes where n, l and m came from.
Key equations
Read the units, assumptions and limits before substituting.
Separated wavefunction
ψ(r, θ, φ) = R(r) Y(θ, φ) = [u(r)/r] Θ(θ) Φ(φ)
Works for any potential that depends on r alone. The Coulomb term never meets the angles, so the angular solutions serve every central force.
r in m, θ and φ in rad; Y is dimensionless on the unit sphere, so R carries m⁻³⁄² and u = rR carries m⁻¹⁄²Azimuthal condition
Φ(φ) = e(imφ) with Φ(φ + 2π) = Φ(φ), so m = 0, ±1, ±2, …
The first integer comes from geometry alone. m never enters the radial equation, so without an applied field E cannot depend on it.
m dimensionless; φ and φ + 2π are one point in space, and any other m gives ψ two values therePolar condition
separation constant = l(l+1), with l = 0, 1, 2, … and |m| ≤ l
Fixes the strength of the centrifugal term before the radial equation is solved. The next topic reads it as L² = l(l+1)ħ².
l dimensionless; any other constant makes Θ(θ) diverge at θ = 0 or θ = π; each l allows 2l + 1 values of mRadial equation
−(ħ²/2m) u″ + Ueff(r) u = E u, with u(0) = 0 and u → 0 as r → ∞
A 1D problem on r > 0. Near 0, u ∝ r(l+1); far out, u ∝ e(−κr) with κ = √(−2mE)/ħ. Demanding both at once is what quantises E.
u = rR in m⁻¹⁄²; ħ = 1.055 × 10⁻³⁴ J s; m = 9.109 × 10⁻³¹ kg; E and Ueff in JEffective radial potential
Ueff(r) = −ke²/r + l(l+1)ħ²/(2mr²)
The second term is the angular kinetic energy L²/(2mr²). It walls off the nucleus for l ≥ 1, so only s states reach r = 0.
k = 1/(4πε₀) = 8.99 × 10⁹ N m² C⁻², e = 1.602 × 10⁻¹⁹ C; for l ≥ 1 the floor is −13.6 eV/[l(l+1)] at r = l(l+1)a₀Termination of the radial series
Eₙ = −ke²/(2a₀n²) = −13.6 eV/n², with n = nᵣ + l + 1
The only energies at which the series stops instead of growing like e(+κr). E depends on nᵣ + l alone, a degeneracy special to 1/r.
a₀ = 4πε₀ħ²/(me²) = 52.9 pm; nᵣ = 0, 1, 2, … is the degree of the radial polynomial, so l ≤ n − 1Interactive lab
Predict first. Explore the model. Compare the result.
Explore the model
Try this. Hold n = 2 and step l from 0 to 2. At l = 1 the level sits 3.40 eV above a −6.80 eV well floor at 2a₀; at l = 2 the whole well lies above −3.40 eV and no state exists, the picture of n ≥ l + 1. Then try l = 3 with n = 4.
Live results
- RADIAL NUMBER nᵣ = n − l − 1
- 0
- LEVEL Eₙ = −13.6 eV/n²
- -3.40 eV
- WELL FLOOR AT r = l(l+1)a₀
- 2 a₀
- CLASSICALLY ALLOWED WIDTH
- 5.66 a₀
Results follow this lesson’s model and assumptions. Displayed values are rounded.
Predict → change one variable → check
Plan a change before running it. Every other input stays at the saved baseline.
Saved baseline. Orbital quantum number l: 1; Principal quantum number n: 2
This experiment is kept only while this page is open. It does not change saved course progress.
Catch the common trap
After the Bohr model it is natural to read n as the angular momentum in units of ħ, so that the ground state carries L = ħ and an n = 3 electron carries 3ħ. In the Coulomb solution n is not an angular-momentum label at all. It is nᵣ + l + 1: the degree of the terminating radial polynomial, plus l, plus one. The angular momentum is fixed separately by l, through L² = l(l+1)ħ², with l anywhere from 0 to n − 1. An n = 3 electron can therefore have L = 0, √2 ħ or √6 ħ, never 3ħ, and the 1s ground state has L = 0, which is what experiment finds. The energy follows n because radial motion carries kinetic energy too: a state with more radial nodes and less angular momentum shares its level with one that has no radial nodes and the most angular momentum the level allows.
Practice & worked examples
3 authored examples. Make an attempt, then reveal the reasoning one step at a time.
EasyExample 1
An electron in hydrogen has l = 1. Find where its effective radial potential is lowest and how deep it is there, then show that the n = 2 level, E₂ = −3.40 eV, lies inside that well and find its classical turning points.
Sketch your answer or reasoning, then compare it with the authored solution. Your writing is not automatically graded or saved.
0 of 5 steps revealed.
- Use ħ²/m = ke²a₀ to write Ueff = ke²[−1/r + l(l+1)a₀/(2r²)], which for l = 1 is ke²(−1/r + a₀/r²).
- dUeff/dr = ke²(1/r² − 2a₀/r³) = 0 at r = 2a₀ = 2 × 52.9 pm = 106 pm.
- There Ueff = ke²(−1/(2a₀) + 1/(4a₀)) = −ke²/(4a₀) = −27.2 eV/4 = −6.80 eV.
- E₂ = −3.40 eV is above −6.80 eV, so the level sits 3.40 eV above the well floor, inside the well.
- Turning points: with ρ = r/a₀, set 27.2 eV × (−1/ρ + 1/ρ²) = −3.40 eV. Dividing by 27.2 eV gives −1/ρ + 1/ρ² = −1/8; multiplying by 8ρ² and rearranging gives ρ² − 8ρ + 8 = 0, so ρ = 4 ± 2√2 = 1.17 or 6.83.
Answer. The floor is at r = 2a₀ = 106 pm, depth −6.80 eV. The n = 2 level lies 3.40 eV above it, with turning points at 1.17a₀ = 62.0 pm and 6.83a₀ = 361 pm.
MediumExample 2
Test the trial function u(r) = r² e(−r/b) in the l = 1 radial equation. Find the one value of b that makes it an exact solution, the energy that goes with it, and the values of n and nᵣ it corresponds to. Give b in pm and E in eV.
Sketch your answer or reasoning, then compare it with the authored solution. Your writing is not automatically graded or saved.
0 of 6 steps revealed.
- Differentiate: u′ = (2r − r²/b) e(−r/b) and u″ = (2 − 4r/b + r²/b²) e(−r/b).
- Substitute into −(ħ²/2m)u″ + [−ke²/r + 2ħ²/(2mr²)]u = Eu and cancel e(−r/b): −ħ²/m + 2ħ²r/(mb) − ħ²r²/(2mb²) − ke²r + ħ²/m = Er².
- The constant terms, −ħ²/m from the kinetic term and +ħ²/m from the centrifugal term, cancel identically. That is why an l = 1 solution must start as r(l+1) = r².
- Terms in r: 2ħ²/(mb) = ke², so b = 2ħ²/(mke²) = 2a₀ = 106 pm.
- Terms in r²: E = −ħ²/(2mb²) = −ħ²/(8ma₀²) = −(ke²/a₀)/8 = −27.2 eV/8 = −3.40 eV.
- The polynomial factor is a constant, degree nᵣ = 0, so n = nᵣ + l + 1 = 2. The check: κ = 1/b = 1/(2a₀) = 1/(na₀), and E = −13.6 eV/2².
Answer. b = 2a₀ = 106 pm and E = −3.40 eV: the 2p radial function, with n = 2 and nᵣ = 0.
HardExample 3
In muonic hydrogen a negative muon of mass 206.77 mₑ replaces the electron around a proton of mass 1836.15 mₑ. Rescale the Coulomb solution to find the ground-state energy and length scale. Then test each idealisation of this lesson with a number: an infinitely heavy nucleus, a point nucleus of charge radius 0.84 fm, and a non-relativistic particle.
Sketch your answer or reasoning, then compare it with the authored solution. Your writing is not automatically graded or saved.
0 of 5 steps revealed.
- The mass enters the radial equation only through ħ²/(2m), and recoil of the nucleus is handled exactly by the reduced mass: μ = (206.77 × 1836.15)/(206.77 + 1836.15) mₑ = 185.84 mₑ.
- E₁ scales with the mass: E₁ = −13.606 eV × 185.84 = −2529 eV ≈ −2.53 keV. Ignoring recoil (mass 206.77 mₑ) would give −2813 eV, 11% too deep, where the same slip costs 0.054% in ordinary hydrogen. The infinite-mass nucleus fails.
- Lengths scale inversely: a = a₀ mₑ/μ = 52.918 pm/185.84 = 0.2847 pm = 285 fm.
- Point nucleus: rₚ/a = 0.84 fm/285 fm = 2.9 × 10⁻³, against 1.6 × 10⁻⁵ in hydrogen, 186 times larger. Still small, so the Coulomb solution is the right start, but a finite-size shift that goes as (rₚ/a)² relative to the binding matters 186² ≈ 3.5 × 10⁴ times more than in hydrogen.
- Non-relativistic: for a 1/r potential the virial theorem gives ⟨T⟩ = −E₁, so vᵣₘₛ = √(2|E₁|/μ). With μc² = 185.84 × 0.511 MeV = 94.96 MeV, vᵣₘₛ/c = √(2 × 2529 eV/94.96 MeV) = 7.30 × 10⁻³ = α, independent of the mass, so relativistic corrections stay at relative size α² ≈ 5 × 10⁻⁵.
Answer. E₁ ≈ −2.53 keV and a ≈ 285 fm. The infinite-mass nucleus fails (11% error; use μ = 185.84 mₑ), the point nucleus survives as a first approximation (rₚ/a ≈ 3 × 10⁻³), and the non-relativistic treatment holds (vᵣₘₛ ≈ αc = 0.0073c).
Quick check
Select an answer and explain it before checking.
Review & continue
The Coulomb-potential Schrödinger equation describes one electron bound by −ke²/r to a fixed point nucleus; separated in spherical coordinates, it has normalisable solutions only for integer m, l and n, with the energy set by n alone.
- Explain the relationship without looking at the equation.
- Check a sign, a unit and a model assumption in your working.
- Return to the lab or worked example if a step is still unclear.